SWEETENER ECONOMICS
Decode Labels & Find True Value
As I’ve guided home cooks through the maze of sugar alternatives, one thing stands out: label reading is key to finding real value. To uncover the true cost of a product, look beyond the number of servings and focus on how sweet each serving really is. Learn how to spot misleading claims and avoid falling for sneaky tactics.
SMARTER SWEETENER SHOPPING
Navigating the realm of sugar alternatives can be a perplexing journey, especially when it comes to deciphering which sweetener offers the best value for your money.
Comparing prices can be tricky because sweeteners don’t always have the same sweetness level. In addition, serving sizes listed on labels can vary significantly.
These inconsistencies make it challenging to accurately compare products and find the best value. That’s where I come in—to guide you through the confusion and help you make informed choices. I'll give you a clear breakdown and an easy-to-follow example on how to evaluate sweetener costs correctly.
HOW TO TELL IF A SWEETENER IS WORTH IT
A Step-by-Step Guide
Sweetener labels often highlight big serving counts or low prices per ounce — but not how much sweetness you’re actually getting.
This quick 3-step guide below will help you spot real value and avoid overpaying for less.
To see how this works in practice, I compared our WhatSugar® Organic Monk Fruit Extract (0.7 oz jar) with a popular monk fruit sold online, TeakiHut (4 oz pouch). Product details are based on publicly available information as of November 2026.

1
Understand Serving Size
Every sweetener has a serving size, but not all serving sizes are equal in sweetness. Here's an example:
-
WhatSugar: 1 serving is as sweet as 3 tsp of sugar (1 Tbsp).
-
TeakiHut: 1 serving is as sweet as 1 tsp of sugar.
Key Question: How much sugar does each serving replace? This tells the Sugar Equivalent Per Serving.
2
Convert Sweetener to Sugar Equivalents
Calculate how much sugar each container replaces. Use this formula:
Total Servings ✖️ Sugar Equivalent Per Serving 🟰 Total Sugar Replaced
-
WhatSugar: 414 servings × 3 tsp = 1,242 tsp (26 cups)
-
TeakiHut: 364 servings × 1 tsp = 364 tsp (7.6 cups)
Conversion: To convert teaspoons to cups, divide the total number of teaspoons by 48 (since 1 cup = 48 teaspoons).
3
Calculate the Price to Replace 1 Cup of Sugar
Now, figure out the cost to replace 1 cup of sugar. Use this formula:
Price ➗ Total Sugar Replaced (cup) 🟰 Cost to Replace 1 Cup Sugar
-
WhatSugar: $30 ➗ 26 cups 🟰 $1.16 per cup
-
TeakiHut: $24 ➗ 7.60 cups 🟰 $3.16 per cup
Result: WhatSugar® is 2.7x more cost-effective than TeakiHut, even though it’s more expensive per ounce.
THE REAL MEASURE OF SWEETENER VALUE
Notice how we found the sweetener with the best value? We calculated how much each costs to replace the same amount of sugar — in this case, 1 cup of sugar.
Why? Because products vary widely in sweetness, and serving sizes differ between brands. That means neither price per ounce nor price per serving tells the whole story.
Let me illustrate the examples above with the same two monk fruit extracts to see how much it costs to replace 1 cup of sugar.

While less concentrated monk fruit extracts (like TeakiHut with 10% mogroside V) might seem more affordable per ounce, high-purity extracts (like WhatSugar® with 50% mogroside V) end up being far more cost-effective when you consider how much they sweeten. In this comparison, WhatSugar® costs about 63% less to replace the same amount of sugar.
Want to learn more about the different types of monk fruit extract and how they compare? Read my Guide to Pure Monk Fruit Extract.
WHY PRICE PER OUNCE FALLS SHORT
Price per ounce tells you how much you're paying for the powder, but it doesn't account for how sweet that powder is. For example:
-
WhatSugar® Monk Fruit:
Costs more per ounce ($42.84), but it’s much sweeter, so you use less. -
TeakiHut Monk Fruit:
It is cheaper per ounce ($6), but it's less sweet, so you need way more.
That's why the product with the lower price per ounce isn't necessarily the better deal.
NUMBER OF SERVINGS IS NOT RELIABLE
The serving size for sweeteners is a key piece of information found on the Nutrition Facts label — and it's directly tied to the product's sweetness level.
Serving sizes are set by the manufacturer. In other words, manufacturers determine the amount of sweetener in a serving, based on their knowledge of the product's sweetness.
By law, a serving is intended to reflect the amount customarily consumed per eating occasion (called a reference amount). But for sugar substitutes, the FDA defines the serving size in terms of sweetness: the amount that provides sweetness equal to one reference amount of sugar.
Here's where it gets tricky: The amount of sugar that one serving is said to replace can vary between products. For some sweeteners, one serving might replace 1 teaspoon of sugar, while another replaces 2 or even 3 teaspoons.
Since servings can represent different amounts of sweetness, simply counting them across products isn't comparing apples to apples. To make a fair comparison, you need to know how much sugar each serving replaces.
Take a look at the examples below.

Both stevia sweeteners above contain over 95% erythritol and come in jars of the same size: 9.8 ounces. Truvía provides 80 servings, while Whole Earth offers 140. At first glance, it might seem like Whole Earth provides nearly double the amount.
However, the serving sizes reveal a different story.
Truvía lists a serving as 3/4 teaspoon, while Whole Earth lists 1/2 teaspoon. When we look at the total sweetness each container provides, Truvía comes out ahead: enough to replace 160 teaspoons (about 3.5 cups of sugar), compared to Whole Earth's 140 teaspoons (about 3 cups). This makes Truvía the more concentrated sweetener.
So even though Whole Earth appears to offer more servings, it actually delivers less total sweetness. This example shows why comparing sweeteners by the number of servings alone can be misleading when evaluating costs.
What matters most is how much sugar a sweetener can replace. That’s the real measure of value.
TAKEAWAY
Now you know why serving sizes vary between sweeteners—and why comparing prices per ounce, prices per serving, or simply counting servings can be misleading.
To find the best value, always ask:
-
How much sugar does this sweetener replace?
-
What’s the cost to replace 1 cup of sugar?
To compare sweetener price, follow these 3 steps:
1. Look for the sweetness of one serving on the label.
2. Calculate how much sugar one container replaces.
3. Divide the price by the number of cups of sugar replaced.
Skip “cheap per ounce” comparisons. This method shows which sweetener truly gives you more.
